If you value the current independent index snapshot, Kimi K3.1 Pro is ahead: Artificial Analysis lists 46 to Qwen4 Max’s 43. If your priority is lower hosted API rates, Qwen4 Max is cheaper at the published Singapore rates. Kimi also offers released open weights; Qwen4 Max’s launch materials describe a hosted service. None is a universal winner, and the vendors’ own coding and professional-work charts are not a controlled head-to-head. A commenter in the launch discussion asked how the two models compare by size, while others cautioned that the index may not match personal use (Reddit discussion).
Qwen4 Max pricing explains its rate card; this page focuses on the model choice.
Key takeaways
Kimi leads the current Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index snapshot, 46 to Qwen4 Max’s 43; this is not a task pass rate.
Qwen4 Max has lower Singapore list rates: $1.50/$4.50 per million input/output tokens vs Kimi’s $2/$10.
Kimi K3.1 Pro has open weights and can be self-hosted; Qwen4 Max is a hosted proprietary model in the checked launch materials.
Both list a one-million-token context, but equal context limits do not mean equal accuracy or cost.
Pick with a same-prompt pilot; vendor benchmark results use different harnesses.
Qwen4 Max vs Kimi K3.1 Pro at a glance
| Dimension | Qwen4 Max | Kimi K3.1 Pro | Decision meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Provider status | Alibaba Cloud GA, Nov 16, 2026 | Moonshot API and products; full weights released by Nov 4 | Hosted API vs API, product and self-host option |
| Weights | Proprietary in release material checked | Open weights on Hugging Face | Self-hosting adds hardware, engineering and ops cost |
| Total model scale | 2.4T total; 71B active/token reported | 3T-class | Vendor descriptions; do not assume scale predicts quality |
| Context | Up to 1M | Up to 1M | Measure retrieval and quality at your actual prompt size |
| Artificial Analysis Index snapshot | 43 | 46 | Same index, checked Nov 17; not a win probability |
| Index task cost estimate | $3.27 | $3.68 | Artificial Analysis task mix and current pricing; not your invoice |
| Singapore API input/output | $1.50/$4.50 per 1M | $2/$10 per 1M | Qwen list rates are lower; cache and deployment differ |
| Output speed snapshot | 54 tokens/s | 31 tokens/s | Provider snapshot; latency varies by load and setup |
Qwen4 Max costs less per token on the published API rates
Alibaba Cloud’s Model Studio pricing table lists Qwen4 Max at $1.50/M input and $4.50/M output in Singapore. The Kimi API platform lists K3.1 Pro at $2/M input and $10/M output. For equal uncached token counts, Qwen’s rate is 25% lower on input and 55% lower on output. This is a rate comparison; different reasoning lengths, cache hits, retries and successful completion rates change the cost per accepted task.
| Hypothetical uncached request | Qwen4 Max | Kimi K3.1 Pro |
|---|---|---|
| 100k input + 10k output | $0.195 | $0.30 |
| 800k input + 100k output | $1.65 | $2.60 |
These are arithmetic examples, not measured model runs. Kimi lists a $0.20/M cache-hit price and $2/M cache write; Qwen4 Max’s Singapore cache read is $0.075/M and five-minute/one-hour writes are $1.875/$3/M. Cache terms are not identical; compare actual logs and current provider rules. Self-hosting Kimi removes per-token API pricing only if infrastructure, quantization, engineering, throughput and maintenance costs are counted separately.
Public benchmark evidence favors Kimi on one shared index
Artificial Analysis currently shows Kimi K3.1 Pro at 46 and Qwen4 Max at 43 on the same Intelligence Index, with estimated index-task costs of $3.68 and $3.27. Its page also lists 31 vs 54 output tokens per second and about 38.8 vs 32.1 minutes per index task. These figures are the closest shared evaluation in this review, but still describe one benchmark suite and a dated snapshot. They do not predict which model will pass your repository tests, follow your style guide or finish a browser task.
Keep vendor evaluations separate. Kimi reports 65.7% on Terminal-Bench 4.0 using a Claude-Code harness and 92.7% on a 1,000-item BenchCAD-with-tools subset. Alibaba reports Qwen4 Max at 48.5 on Terminal-Bench 4.0 and 52.69 on its Work360 benchmark. Kimi’s own Terminal-Bench comparison and Qwen’s launch chart do not disclose a shared run, so don’t rank those numbers as if they came from one controlled test. Work360 and BenchCAD measure different task types.
Community reports add useful caveats, not a model ranking. In one Atomic Agent Reddit post, the author describes a single Three.js scene task and discloses a temperature mismatch that prevented Kimi from reviewing its screenshots; the author said the rerun would be fairer (original post). Another Kimi user described failed Luau tests but supplied no prompts or logs (anecdote). These opposite experiences show why anecdotes need task and setup details.
Choose by deployment and task
| Your situation | Start with | Why | Validate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Need managed API at lower token rates | Qwen4 Max | Lower published Singapore input/output rates | Accepted-task cost, retries and regional rate |
| Need open weights or private deployment | Kimi K3.1 Pro | Weights are available for self-hosting | Hardware, quantization, throughput, license and ops |
| Long agentic coding | Pilot both | Kimi reports strong long-horizon results; AA snapshot favors Kimi slightly | Same repo issues, tests, tools, time and repair effort |
| 3D or visual workflow | Pilot both with same tool chain | Kimi’s official BenchCAD result is tool-assisted; Qwen supports native vision | Asset quality, tool use, revisions and whether external skills are involved |
| Long documents | Tie until tested | Both advertise up to 1M context | Retrieval accuracy, omissions, latency and total input cost |
Run a fair pilot before switching
Use three representative tasks: a code change with tests, a long-document comparison, and an agent task with a visible acceptance check. Freeze prompt, files, tools, model setting, provider region and timeout. Run each task several times; save outputs, input/cache/output token counts, tool calls, elapsed time, retries, accepted outcome and human edits. Calculate total cost across all attempts / accepted tasks. For Kimi self-hosting, add compute and maintenance. Keep failed and unfinished runs in the denominator.
Tabbit can help open the two official release pages, current rate tables, benchmark methodology and your test notes side by side. See the Tabbit browser guide, Qwen4 Max review, Qwen4 Max pricing, Qwen4 Max preview, Kimi K3.1 Pro pricing, Kimi K3.1 Pro review, Qwen4 model page, Kimi model page, and agentic reasoning guide.
Verdict: choose the constraint you cannot compromise
Choose Qwen4 Max first when managed API price and hosted access matter most. Choose Kimi K3.1 Pro when open weights, local/private deployment options or the current AA index lead matter more—and budget for infrastructure if self-hosting. For a production migration, run the same tasks through both and compare accepted-work cost and quality. A three-point index gap or lower list rate alone is not enough.
Tabbit Browser offers Qwen4-Max. Download Tabbit, then select Qwen4-Max from the model list in Chat to start using it.
FAQ
Which model is better, Qwen4 Max or Kimi K3.1 Pro?
Artificial Analysis currently scores Kimi at 46 and Qwen4 Max at 43 on its Intelligence Index. That is one shared index snapshot, not a guarantee for your workload.
Is Qwen4 Max cheaper than Kimi K3.1 Pro?
At published Singapore/API list rates, Qwen4 Max is cheaper per uncached input and output token. Actual task cost depends on tokens, cache, retries and successful completion.
Can I run Kimi K3.1 Pro locally?
Kimi K3.1 Pro weights are available, but self-hosting requires suitable hardware and engineering. Qwen4 Max is not listed as open weights in the checked release material.
Do their benchmark scores compare directly?
Only Artificial Analysis provides a shared index snapshot in this review. Vendor Terminal-Bench, Work360 and BenchCAD results use distinct setups and should not be combined into one ranking.
Can I use Qwen4-Max in Tabbit?
Tabbit Browser offers Qwen4-Max. Download Tabbit, then select Qwen4-Max from the model list in Chat to start using it.